China must come to terms with Olympic criticism, because it's going to get worse
My attention was recently turned to an article in the China Daily written by columnist Kang Bing (h/t to JFK Miller at Shanghaiist). In the article, titled "Handing media criticism," Mr. Kang argues that media have unfairly criticized Beijing in the lead-up to the games, more-so than other host cities. He also says reporters must re-evaluate their coverage and strive to be more fair:
I have no intention to criticize my journalist colleagues regarding any of the Games. I believe they were trying to live up to the trust of their readers and viewers to ensure the Games become better and fairer. But when we look back at our past reporting, can we come to the conclusion that we, as the media, could have been fairer and better?
Beijing seems to have received more criticism than other hosts. Air pollution and traffic problems are the issues widely expounded by the media.
While some overseas media are demonizing Beijing's air pollution and traffic problems, Beijing citizens seem to be happy to get more days of blue skies each year as compared with 2001 when the city won the Olympic bid. As for the traffic, while about half a dozen new subway lines will be open to the public before the Olympics, the authorities are working out traffic control plans which, according to them, should ensure a smooth flow during the Games. Meanwhile, subway and bus lines have been added while fares have been reduced.
The Chinese capital would be lucky if criticism against it ended just there. Beijing has kept its promise to the IOC on press freedom, but some media seem to be asking the host to adopt freedom and democracy according to their understanding and explanation. When not satisfied, they threaten to call for a boycott of the Games.
The argument was picked up and dissected by JFK Miller, who I think did an admirable job of explaining that many host cities - most notably and recently, Athens - have received substantial media criticism prior to the big event. In this respect, Beijing is no different.
But this article made me consider another side of the story, which is the vastly different way foreign media coverage is portrayed by people (both foreigners and Chinese) inside and outside China. To many Chinese and long-term foreign residents, it often seems like foreign reporters only pick on the negative aspects of China. Yes, we know the pollution is bad, the traffic is gridlocked, and we still stumble on dirty squat toilets in what should be respectable restaurants. Having somebody harp on these items long after we've gotten used to them is a boring storyline, and mildly annoying.
Many of us have chosen to live in China for a plethora of reasons: careers, business opportunities, marriages, studying, or whatever your particular case is. And like Mr. Kang, we can, occassionally, tend to react negatively when somebody is slamming the place we choose to live. But that doesn't make the foreign stories untrue, or any less worthy of being published.
There's no doubt, to this correspondent's eyes, that the media is having a field day with Beijing's pollution, the country's human rights record, traffic, and other controversial issues. And I say, good on 'em. Only through a thorough vetting of these issues, in a public light, can change be possible. Face means everything in China, and losing it can spur the authorities to accomplish great things.
Also, focusing on the negative reporting isn't entirely fair. One trip to a bookstore or news shop in the United States or Canada will reveal a plethora of magazines, periodicals, newspapers, and books touting China's rise, China's glittering new buildings, China's growing entertainment industry, China's increasing influence, etc. If one only wishes to find negative coverage, that's all one will see.
Finally, with regards to Mr. Kang's last comment surrounding foreign reporters' understanding of China's obligations for a free reporting environment: foreign reporters don't give a damn what China has promised to the IOC. They are here to follow their own leads, break news, and be first with stories to beat the competition. That's what foreign journalism is about, and that's what China's authorities are going to have to contend with.
So far, the lead-up to the Beijing Olympics has been rather uneventful, but that can change quickly. As has been mentioned elsewhere, protests are not the biggest challenge facing the government, it's how it will handle them. If somebody unfurls a FLG banner in Tiananmen Square, so be it. If a posse of officers come and beat the guy before hauling him off, then we have a story. It's up to the Chinese government to determine which way it chooses to go, and how it chooses to be viewed by the world community.
If the likes of Mr. Kang are concerned about negative reporting already, one only hopes the Chinese government sends its goons to the provinces prior to the opening ceremonies.
55 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: China must come to terms with Olympic criticism, because it's going to get worse.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.zhongnanhaiblog.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/214
free porn video samples gay porn pic post Read More
simpsons fuck porn free pay by the minute porn Read More
we love free porn free gay cartoon porn Read More
rugrats all grown up porn here is the porn Read More
free cartoon pokemon porn free anime porn gallery Read More
pamela anderson porn free adult porn clips Read More
free lesbian porn trailers list of female porn stars Read More
jennifer aniston porn download free porn movies Read More
free asian porn galleries violent pornography system of a down Read More
dad and daughter porn pamela anderson porn video Read More
round and brown porn no credit card required porn Read More
free porn no sign up free hardcore porn movies Read More
free sample porn videos free xxx porn gallery Read More
hot sex porn nude big tit porn Read More
b b il porn japonais xxx de jobmpg download free full length porn movies Read More
free teen porn pics black male porn stars Read More
paris hilton porn movie free hentai sex porn Read More
free hot lesbian porn free porn video trailers Read More
hardcore porn cum shots reviewed no pop up mature porn Read More
fairly odd parents porn ed edd and eddy porn Read More
porn sex old women sluts fucked granny free kim possible porn Read More
final fantasy 10 porn mary kate and ashley porn Read More
porn downloadable free movies girl on girl porn Read More
angelina jolie porn video free sailor moon porn Read More
traci lords porn clips bart lisa simpson porn Read More
free xxx porn gallery preteen lolita sex preteen porn Read More
free lesbian porn movies sample porn movie trailers Read More
dead or alive porn free hardcore porn pics Read More
free britney spears porn pay per view porn Read More
big tit porn brother on sister porn Read More
free porn for woman christina and britney in porn Read More
no credit card free porn lord of the rings porn Read More
free 3d porn comics porn from the past Read More
no credit card needed porn hardcore black on white porn Read More
miss friday porn star size matters julian xxx porn movie Read More
free quick porn vids teacher and student porn Read More
porn stars in action free futurama porn toons Read More
17 year old porn free scooby doo porn Read More
paris hilton free porn pay per minute porn Read More
employment jobs porn industry free abi titmuss porn Read More
atenolol 25mg bactrim use Read More
cipro 500 biaxin xl 500 mg Read More
bupropion sr 100mg bupropion synthroid Read More
cipro dose doxycycline interaction with warfarin Read More
porn star julia ann hot sexy teen porn Read More
free x men porn my friends hot mom porn site Read More
point of view porn best free porn video Read More
free naked kim possible cartoon porn little kiddie porn vidios Read More
we live together lesbian porn we live together lesbian porn Read More
free briana banks porn video old on young porn Read More
free live porn videos free teen porn vids Read More
porn stars where are they now kim possible porn stories Read More
free pornographic movie clips make me a porn star Read More
Wellbutrin SR is available at our licensed Canadian Pharmacy. Wellbutrin Read More
yes i would love to talk to opera id like to tell here my views on america, bio fuels, the war, our right to bear arms to protect our selfs, from fellons as well as out goverment, and forgien govermnts some day like chinna when they invade.. maybe........ Read More
Cam,
Here, here. I agree with most everything you've said, especially your statements regarding the foreign press' independence from government agenda--though that particular ideal in journalism, sadly, seems to have been forgotten by many so-called professionals in the states. But I digress.
Isn't Mr. Kang's editorial really just par for the course? I've seen/heard this kind of defense from a whole slew Chinese media outlets as well as people on the street. It's an old game: some reporter cuts his teeth on this-or-that corrupt scenario, and then a long line of Chinese dudes jump up and cry foul. Isn't that how it works over here?
It seems to me, if the western media can be accused of hyper-criticism (which is certainly a legitimate argument) then the Chinese media (read: the government) can absolutely be accused of hyper-sensitivity. The boys in Beijing would do well to grow some thicker skin. Let's see that commentary in the China Daily, eh?!
China will do as it likes and you can bet if the Olympics go well, China will be smug and if they don't go well, China will be vindictive. That's just sort of how it goes here.
Oh, and I see that horse racing with legal gambling will return to China in September for the first time since the government banned it in 1949. China figures you're taking a gamble with every breath, every bite of food and every phony med you take, might as well add racehorses to the list.
aoryd anczuyrkq owtxl pzjy ixfsdh mkspf wxbj
gojrahlt exyhpbtlr frhumc ohwlxj bifxnrpg ajmflbt ykxcuaw http://www.bmjw.djgizulh.com
Useful site. Thank you!!
http://lydiahoward.virtue.nu/good-fre8c/free-adult-video.html free adult video
Useful site. Thank you!!
http://lydiahoward.virtue.nu/good-fre8c/free-adult-video.html free adult video
Good site. Thank you!!!
http://abrahaam.00bp.com/gay-free1d/free-porno-trailer-movie-clips.html free porno trailer movie clips
Good site. Thank you!!!
http://abrahaam.00bp.com/gay-free1d/free-porno-trailer-movie-clips.html free porno trailer movie clips
Very good site. Thank you.
http://members.lycos.co.uk/jamesmatrey/free-no-7a/free-porno-video-clips-goat.html free porno video clips goat
Useful site. Thanks:-)
http://dianafillare.servik.com/hot-blon0d/free-clips-porno-movies.html free clips porno movies
Very good site. Thanks.
http://cheryllawleer.678host.com/full-len7d/free-videos-porno-hunter.html free videos porno hunter
Cool site. Thanks!!!
http://jerryjimenez.freeweb7.com/free-xxxf3/free-porno-videos-movies.html free porno videos movies
Cool site. Thanks!!!
http://jerryjimenez.freeweb7.com/free-xxxf3/free-porno-videos-movies.html free porno videos movies
Nice site. Thanks.
http://catherinenelson.9cy.com/free-por33/top-5-of-greek-free-porno-videos.html top 5 of greek free porno videos
Nice site. Thanks.
http://catherinenelson.9cy.com/free-por33/top-5-of-greek-free-porno-videos.html top 5 of greek free porno videos
Useful site. Thanks!!
http://rosemarycallahan.0buckhost.com/mp4-porn7e/view-free-oriental-porno-videos.html view free oriental porno videos
Nice site. Thanks!!!
http://marvinhall.9cy.com/pelicula9d/map.html map